March 10, 2024

To test your values, rephrase the question

By Matt Lehrman

Social Prosperity Partners


Defining mission, vision and values is a powerful tool for any organization, but it’s not the rhetoric of such statements that matters so much as their ability to inform practical decision-making at all levels.


To test whether your organization’s thoughtfully crafted principles are doing the job, sometimes it helps to rephrase the question. For example, I was in Nebraska recently facilitating separate (but identical) annual planning retreats for the Fremont City Council and the city’s senior staff. The City’s official values statement is: “Strong Leadership,” “Public Safety,” “Fiscally Responsible,” “Quality of Life,” and “Teamwork” — all strong, results-oriented phrases. But are they the most important values driving both Council members and their professional staff?

To find out, I asked each group what qualities, rather than values, energized them in pursuit of their stated mission, even in challenging times. Both expressed a commitment to “Service,” and beyond that, it was fascinating to hear Council members orient to “Public Trust” and accountability to “The Future,” while staffers emphasized the importance of “Professionalism” and “Teamwork.”


My advice to the Fremont City Council (shared with their permission) was that their currently stated values are well-chosen promises to residents, but this shouldn’t stop them from continuing to explore the values — er, sorry, qualities — that inform how they work together to accomplish those goals.


3 KEYS TO A VALUES STATEMENT THAT LASTS


A values statement isn’t about branding, marketing, public relations or virtue signaling. The purpose of articulating the foundational beliefs of an organization is to make sure they continue guiding actions and decisions.

 

Here are three keys to a values statement that will serve as a lasting beacon:


  1. Universality: The statement should apply across all levels of the organization, from leadership to frontline staff.
  2. Discernment: The values should embody distinct choices or priorities to decide among potentially conflicting option
  3. Authenticity: These values must be derived from observed behaviors and actions, not just lofty ideals or noble rhetoric.


Finally, it’s crucial to avoid temptingly vague words like “excellence,” “transparency” or “inclusivity,” which are unquestionably expected of every municipal entity and nonprofit organization. If you can’t imagine one that publicly embraces the opposite of those qualities, then what’s the point of including them?


Community Catalyst podcast.

 NEW EPISODE — “BACK IN BLACK” (March 12, 2024)

As the first woman and first African American mayor of her Cleveland suburb, Annette Blackwell endured a social media backlash while turning around the city’s finances. Her biggest challenge, however, wasn’t winning over white voters, but her fellow Black politicians.


Listen on Apple, Spotify and all podcast platforms

CLICK HERE TO LISTEN


“THE WELLNESS POLICE” (March 5, 2024)

“CHURCH & STATE” (February 27, 2024)

Connect with Matt:


6 Practical Tips for Building Stronger Communities by Matt Lehrman of Social Prosperity Partners

6 Practical Tips for Building Stronger Communities

By Matt Lehrman • February 21, 2025
I had the pleasure of hosting our latest Local Leadership Chat, where local leaders from across the country gathered on Zoom to discuss the challenges and opportunities of civic communication in a rapidly evolving media environment. The conversation was lively, insightful, and filled with practical advice for navigating the complexities of public engagement.
Mayor Ginny Dickey, Fountain Hills, AZ on Community Catalysts

Mayor Ginny Dickey, Fountain Hills, AZ

By Matt Lehrman • February 19, 2025
Former Mayor Ginny Dickey of Fountain Hills, Arizona, gives an unflinching account of how local politics took a dark turn. Having lost her 2024 reelection bid, Mayor Dickey reflects on the rise of vicious, unprincipled attacks—tactics that had nothing to do with policy or leadership and everything to do with fueling anger and spreading division.
Mayor Brian Vincent of Farmville, VA is on the Community Catalysts Podcast.

Mayor Brian Vincent of Farmville, VA

By Matt Lehrman • February 12, 2025
It’s common to hear a mayor speak about high ideals or how their town bridges its history with its future. But Mayor Vincent is anything but common. When he talks about “decency, fortitude, and community” in Farmville, you quickly discover the profound influence of his father, a fallen U.S. Army officer. His father’s service and sacrifice embody the power of leading not with force, but with quiet strength and unwavering dedication to others—a painful yet timeless lesson in leadership from which we can all learn.
More Posts
Share by: